Skip to main content

Chinese timber supplier Superb Summit International Group has described comments by independent research firm Muddy Waters last November that questioned its accounts as "misleading" without providing further clarification.

Superb Summit's comment, issued in a statement late on Tuesday, was the Hong Kong-listed company's first official reaction to a critical Muddy Waters research note issued on Nov. 20. The company, whose shares have been suspended since then, said it would publish a clarification "in due course".

In its Tuesday statement, Superb Summit said the Muddy Waters report "contained misleading statements and fabricated contents to asperse the company and its subsidiaries." Worth about $1.5 billion by market value, Superb Summit has its operations in mainland China.

The research firm questioned the timber company's balance sheet and the value of assets it owns in its November report. Its founder, Carson Block, is a short-seller who has exposed accounting problems at a slew of Chinese firms.

Muddy Waters' Block did not immediately respond to an email requesting comment on the Superb Summit reaction.

Questions over accounting at several other Chinese-listed companies in the past year have left clouds over investing in Chinese stocks at a time when Beijing is keen to lure investors through a recently created trade link between Hong Kong and Shanghai.

Before last November's suspension, Superb Summit's shares had nearly quadrupled in value over a period 12 months compared with a rise of 5.8 percent in Hong Kong's main Hang Seng Index, Thomson Reuters data show.

The bulk of that rally occurred in the run-up to Superb Summit's acquisition of an 80 percent stake in a Chinese coal liquefaction company, Beijing Jin Fe Te, in May 2014. In its report, Muddy Waters challenged the value of that asset.

 

Related Articles

报名开始:2025 ALB China十五佳出海业务律师 / Submission open: 2025 ALB China Top 15 Overseas Investment Lawyers

ALB聚焦于企业出海尤其是律师在助力企业的出海中的重要角色,于2025年推出首个出海业务律师榜单——2025 ALB China十五佳出海业务律师。

2024 ALB China天达共和十五佳总法律顾问圆桌会议成功举办 (ZH/EN)

10月18日,2024 ALB天达共和十五佳总法律顾问圆桌会议在北京璞瑄酒店圆满举办。 本次盛会由天达共和律师事务所品牌运营总监刘思强女士主持,十五佳上榜总法及获奖代表出席了此次盛会。

功承瀛泰落子武汉,拓展华中布局(ZH/EN)

by Charlie Wu 吴卓言 |

总部位于上海的功承瀛泰律师事务所近日正式成立武汉办公室,成为该所在全国范围内的第16家分支机构。